Personal tools
Document Actions

Shirky and Sanger, or the costs of crowdsourcing

22/03/2010

Abstract

Online knowledge production sites do not rely on isolated experts but on collaborative processes, on the wisdom of the group or “crowd”. Some authors have argued that it is possible to combine traditional or credentialled expertise with collective production; others believe that traditional expertise's focus on correctness has been superseded by the affordances of digital networking, such as re-use and verifiability. This paper examines the costs of two kinds of “crowdsourced” encyclopedic projects: Citizendium, based on the work of credentialled and identified experts, faces a recruitment deficit; in contrast Wikipedia has proved wildly popular, but anti-credentialism and anonymity result in uncertainty, irresponsibility, the development of cliques and the growing importance of pseudo-legal competencies for conflict resolution. Finally the paper reflects on the wider social implications of focusing on what experts are rather than on what they are for.

download

2014 Conference
2014 Conference

New Program
Master Classes
Framing engagement: expert-youth interaction in a PES event Sampsa Saikkonen, Esa Valiverronen 08/04/2014
Narrative as a learning tool in science centers: potentials, possibilities and merits Mai Murmann, Lucy Avraamidou 02/04/2014
Examining perceptions of astronomy images across mobile platforms Lisa F. Smith, Kimberly K. Arcand, Jeffrey K. Smith, Randall K. Smith, Jay Bookbinder, Megan Watzke 25/03/2014
Communicating evolution with a Dynamic Evolutionary Map Sonia H. Stephens 13/03/2014
All articles…
Science blogs and public engagement with science: practices, challenges, and opportunities Inna Kouper 26/02/2010
Museums for Science Education: can we make the difference? The case of the EST project Maria Xanthoudaki, Brunella Tirelli, Patrizia Cerutti, Sara Calcagnini 21/06/2007
Changing the meaning of peer-to-peer? Exploring online comment spaces as sites of negotiated expertise Marie-Claire Shanahan 22/02/2010