Personal tools
Home Archive volume 09, 2010 Issue 01, march 2010. Special issue Changing the meaning of peer-to-peer? Exploring online comment spaces as sites of negotiated expertise
Document Actions

Changing the meaning of peer-to-peer? Exploring online comment spaces as sites of negotiated expertise

22/02/2010

Abstract

This study examines the nature of peer-to-peer interactions in public online comment spaces. From a theoretical perspective of boundary-work and expertise, the comments posted in response to three health sciences news articles from a national newspaper are explored to determine whether both scientific and personal expertise are recognized and taken up in discussion. Posts were analysed for both explicit claims to expertise and implicit claims embedded in discourse. The analysis suggests that while both scientific and personal expertise are proffered by commenters, it is scientific expertise that is privileged. Those expressing scientific expertise receive greater recognition of the value of their posts. Contributors seeking to share personal expertise are found to engage in scientisation to position themselves as worthwhile experts. Findings suggest that despite the possibilities afforded by online comments for a broader vision of what peer-to-peer interaction means, this possibility is not realized.

download

Editorials Articles Comments Reviews Letters Focus
2014 Conference
2014 Conference

New Program
Master Classes
Framing engagement: expert-youth interaction in a PES event Sampsa Saikkonen, Esa Valiverronen 08/04/2014
Narrative as a learning tool in science centers: potentials, possibilities and merits Mai Murmann, Lucy Avraamidou 02/04/2014
Examining perceptions of astronomy images across mobile platforms Lisa F. Smith, Kimberly K. Arcand, Jeffrey K. Smith, Randall K. Smith, Jay Bookbinder, Megan Watzke 25/03/2014
Communicating evolution with a Dynamic Evolutionary Map Sonia H. Stephens 13/03/2014
All articles…
Science blogs and public engagement with science: practices, challenges, and opportunities Inna Kouper 26/02/2010
Museums for Science Education: can we make the difference? The case of the EST project Maria Xanthoudaki, Brunella Tirelli, Patrizia Cerutti, Sara Calcagnini 21/06/2007
Changing the meaning of peer-to-peer? Exploring online comment spaces as sites of negotiated expertise Marie-Claire Shanahan 22/02/2010