Personal tools
Home Archive volume 09, 2010 Issue 01, march 2010. Special issue Changing the meaning of peer-to-peer? Exploring online comment spaces as sites of negotiated expertise
Document Actions

Changing the meaning of peer-to-peer? Exploring online comment spaces as sites of negotiated expertise

22/02/2010

Abstract

This study examines the nature of peer-to-peer interactions in public online comment spaces. From a theoretical perspective of boundary-work and expertise, the comments posted in response to three health sciences news articles from a national newspaper are explored to determine whether both scientific and personal expertise are recognized and taken up in discussion. Posts were analysed for both explicit claims to expertise and implicit claims embedded in discourse. The analysis suggests that while both scientific and personal expertise are proffered by commenters, it is scientific expertise that is privileged. Those expressing scientific expertise receive greater recognition of the value of their posts. Contributors seeking to share personal expertise are found to engage in scientisation to position themselves as worthwhile experts. Findings suggest that despite the possibilities afforded by online comments for a broader vision of what peer-to-peer interaction means, this possibility is not realized.

download

Editorials Articles Essays Comments

Reader survey

Dear Reader, we are planning new developments for JCOM. This survey is designed to collect your opinions and suggestions.
It won't take more than a few minutes - please click here to answer.
Many thanks!

Special Issue on citizen science


Call for papers

Insightful and thought provoking papers on citizen science sought for themed issue.


Courses

Master Classes

New articles

When quotes matter: impact of outside quotes in a science press release on news judgment Paige Brown Jarreau 01/12/2014
The Holy Grail of energy? A content and thematic analysis of the presentation of nuclear fusion on the Internet Christian Oltra, Ana Delicado, Ana Prades, Sergio Pereira, Luisa Schmidt 17/11/2014
Science blogging: an exploratory study of motives, styles, and audience reactions Merja Mahrt, Cornelius Puschmann 22/09/2014
Slovenian social scientists’ understanding of public knowledge and participation in sustainable development: from deficit to mutual learning Pika Zaloznik 22/09/2014
All articles…

Most viewed

When quotes matter: impact of outside quotes in a science press release on news judgment Paige Brown Jarreau 01/12/2014
Public communication from research institutes: is it science communication or public relations? Rebecca B. Carver 22/09/2014
The Holy Grail of energy? A content and thematic analysis of the presentation of nuclear fusion on the Internet Christian Oltra, Ana Delicado, Ana Prades, Sergio Pereira, Luisa Schmidt 17/11/2014
Science festivals: do they succeed in reaching beyond the ‘already engaged’? Karen Bultitude 19/12/2014
Science blogging: an exploratory study of motives, styles, and audience reactions Merja Mahrt, Cornelius Puschmann 22/09/2014